Too Faced Melted Matte Dupes for Every Shade

The Cult Appeal of Too Faced Melted Matte

Too Faced Melted Matte Liquid Lipstick has long been a staple in the makeup bags of beauty enthusiasts worldwide. Known for its lightweight, long-wearing formula and intense pigment payoff, it’s a product that delivers on its promises. Infused with Volulip for a no-sting plumping effect and Avocado Oil to keep lips hydrated, it manages to provide a matte finish without the dreaded "cracked earth" look that many liquid lipsticks suffer from.

However, at $26 per tube, building a full collection can quickly become an expensive endeavor. Whether you're a fan of the dusty mauve of Queen B, the perfect neutral nude of Sell Out, or the show-stopping red of Lady Balls, finding a too faced melted matte dupe can help you achieve the same high-end look for a fraction of the cost. The drugstore has made incredible strides in liquid lipstick technology, offering formulas that rival prestige brands in both longevity and comfort.

Top Dupes for Iconic Melted Matte Shades

One of the most requested dupes is for the shade Queen B, a stunning dusty mauve that complements almost every skin tone. If you're looking for an affordable alternative, the NYX Soft Matte Lip Cream in 'Cannes' or Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink in 'Lover' provide a very similar color profile and matte finish. While the NYX formula is slightly creamier and less "locked-in" than the Melted Matte, the color match is nearly identical.

For those who swear by the neutral nude Sell Out, you can't go wrong with Milani Amore Matte Lip Crème in 'Adored'. It offers that same sophisticated, understated elegance that makes Sell Out a daily go-to for so many. If you're looking for a match for the fiery red Lady Balls, look no further than ColourPop Ultra Matte Lip in 'Creeper'. It’s a bold, blue-toned red that stays put through meals and long nights out, just like the original.

Formula Comparison: High-End vs. Drugstore

When searching for a too faced melted matte dupe, it’s not just about the color; the formula matters too. Too Faced's version is unique because it stays flexible on the lips. To get a similar experience from the drugstore, you want to look for "flexible matte" or "ink" formulas. The Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink is arguably the closest in terms of staying power—it actually might even outlast the Too Faced version, though it can feel a bit tackier during the initial dry-down.

Another great option is the L'Oréal Paris Infallible Matte Resistance Liquid Lipstick. This formula is incredibly lightweight and provides a blurred, soft-focus matte finish that mimics the "melted" look perfectly. It doesn't have the same plumping ingredients as Too Faced, but for under $15, the comfort and pigment are unmatched. You can often find these and other Trending Shades on our app, where we compare real-world swatches to help you decide.

How to Make Your Drugstore Dupe Last Longer

Even the best dupe can use a little help to perform like a luxury product. To ensure your affordable matte lipstick looks its best, start with a smooth canvas. Exfoliate your lips with a sugar scrub and apply a light layer of balm, blotting off the excess before applying your liquid lipstick. This prevents the matte formula from clinging to dry patches, a common issue with both high-end and budget products.

Applying in thin layers is also key. Many people make the mistake of applying too much product at once, which leads to flaking and uneven wear. If you’re unsure which drugstore brand offers the best match for your favorite Too Faced shade, our Dupe Finder is an invaluable tool for scanning thousands of products to find the perfect chemical and color match.

Ready to find your perfect shade? Skip the guesswork — try POUT's free Shade Matcher and discover your match in seconds.