POUT
DupesBrandsTrendingKitsCommunityBlogPartnersScan
Scan

POUT

Snap. Match. Shop.

How It Works·Scan·Blog·Partners·Contact·Privacy Policy·Terms

Stay in the loop

© 2026 POUT · Made with color science

Color matching uses CIEDE2000 perceptual algorithms. Results may vary based on lighting and camera quality.

POUT may earn commission from purchases made through our links.

Benefit Cosmetics

#191416

Benefit Cosmetics

Toffee 42

Benefit Cosmetics They're Real!

satinmid-rangeDark

$29.46

Shop This Shade

Similar Shades

Closest matches by CIEDE2000 color distance.

Fenty Beauty

Intense Black 3

100%

$24.15

Urban Decay

Burgundy W1

100%

$23.74

Essence

Light Waterproof Black

93%

$4.87

MAC

Brown Black

93%

$23.38

Revlon

Green 30

90%

$10.99

Cheaper Alternatives

Closest drugstore matches — same color, smaller price tag.

Essence

Light Waterproof Black

93%

$4.87

Revlon

Green 30

90%

$10.99

Essence

Waterproof Brown 37

89%

$5.02

L'Oréal Paris

Espresso WC3

88%

$13.01

Revlon

Dark Brown 6

87%

$7.32

Luxury Upgrades

Closest luxury matches for a premium experience.

Lancôme

True Plum

89%

$26.56

Pat McGrath Labs

Navy Blue SPF

88%

$31.28

Lancôme

Blue Black 20

88%

$26.18

Lancôme

Rich Noir

87%

$25.98

Charlotte Tilbury

Blue Black

87%

$28.39

Community Swatches

Real photos from POUT community members.

No swatches yet for this shade.

Be the first to contribute!

Explore More

All Benefit Cosmetics ShadesDark LipsticksFind Your ShadeBlog

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I buy Benefit Cosmetics Toffee 42?
You can shop Benefit Cosmetics Toffee 42 from the Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! line through our affiliate link on POUT. It retails for $29.46.
What are dupes for Benefit Cosmetics Toffee 42?
POUT uses CIEDE2000 color science to find the closest matches. Check the "Similar Shades" section above for the top 5 closest matches to Toffee 42.
Is Benefit Cosmetics Toffee 42 matte or glossy?
Benefit Cosmetics Toffee 42 has a satin finish.