POUT
DupesBrandsTrendingKitsCommunityBlogPartnersScan
Scan

POUT

Snap. Match. Shop.

How It Works·Scan·Blog·Partners·Contact·Privacy Policy·Terms

Stay in the loop

© 2026 POUT · Made with color science

Color matching uses CIEDE2000 perceptual algorithms. Results may vary based on lighting and camera quality.

POUT may earn commission from purchases made through our links.

Make Up For Ever

#1F6240

Make Up For Ever

Pewter 5

Make Up For Ever Eye Color Quad

mattemid-rangeDark

$22.80

Shop This Shade

Similar Shades

Closest matches by CIEDE2000 color distance.

Chanel

Carbon 32

87%

$44.17

Anastasia Beverly Hills

Cayenne Plus

83%

$14.81

Milani

Opal

83%

$9.92

Annabelle

Rich Chocolate

81%

$8.99

Benefit

beyond green

79%

$31.00

Cheaper Alternatives

Closest drugstore matches — same color, smaller price tag.

Milani

Opal

83%

$9.92

NYX Professional Makeup

Glitter

77%

$7.68

NYX Professional Makeup

Aurora

71%

$5.57

Maybelline

Prism

68%

$7.69

NYX Professional Makeup

Sienna N5

63%

$8.75

Luxury Upgrades

Closest luxury matches for a premium experience.

Chanel

Carbon 32

87%

$44.17

Chanel

Ash 47

74%

$42.83

Fenty Beauty

Midnight Wasabi - Wicked Green

73%

$22.00

Chanel

Black Coffee

64%

$46.42

Charlotte Tilbury

Rich Terracotta

63%

$42.58

Community Swatches

Real photos from POUT community members.

No swatches yet for this shade.

Be the first to contribute!

Explore More

All Make Up For Ever ShadesDark LipsticksFind Your ShadeBlog

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I buy Make Up For Ever Pewter 5?
You can shop Make Up For Ever Pewter 5 from the Make Up For Ever Eye Color Quad line through our affiliate link on POUT. It retails for $22.80.
What are dupes for Make Up For Ever Pewter 5?
POUT uses CIEDE2000 color science to find the closest matches. Check the "Similar Shades" section above for the top 5 closest matches to Pewter 5.
Is Make Up For Ever Pewter 5 matte or glossy?
Make Up For Ever Pewter 5 has a matte finish.