POUT
DupesBrandsTrendingKitsCommunityBlogPartnersScan
Scan

POUT

Snap. Match. Shop.

How It Works·Scan·Blog·Partners·Contact·Privacy Policy·Terms

Stay in the loop

© 2026 POUT · Made with color science

Color matching uses CIEDE2000 perceptual algorithms. Results may vary based on lighting and camera quality.

POUT may earn commission from purchases made through our links.

Rare Beauty

#141411

Rare Beauty

Toffee 2

Rare Beauty Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes

satinmid-rangeDark

$23.70

Shop This Shade

Similar Shades

Closest matches by CIEDE2000 color distance.

Clinique

Navy NW5

100%

$18.26

Essence

Navy Plus

100%

$4.73

MAC

Rich Brownish Black

100%

$25.29

Rare Beauty

Rich Brown C9

100%

$19.57

Maybelline

Blue Black

93%

$11.08

Cheaper Alternatives

Closest drugstore matches — same color, smaller price tag.

Essence

Navy Plus

100%

$4.73

NYX Professional Makeup

Blackest Black Ultra

93%

$11.61

Maybelline

Blue Black

93%

$11.08

Maybelline

Toffee 19

93%

$12.44

NYX Professional Makeup

Intense Black 31

93%

$11.18

Luxury Upgrades

Closest luxury matches for a premium experience.

Hourglass

Navy Blue Pro

93%

$31.32

Charlotte Tilbury

Medium Brown Black

93%

$30.52

Chanel

Black Noir

93%

$36.06

Pat McGrath Labs

Ultra Black

93%

$31.07

Hourglass

Eggplant

93%

$31.04

Community Swatches

Real photos from POUT community members.

No swatches yet for this shade.

Be the first to contribute!

Explore More

All Rare Beauty ShadesDark LipsticksFind Your ShadeBlog

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I buy Rare Beauty Toffee 2?
You can shop Rare Beauty Toffee 2 from the Rare Beauty Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes line through our affiliate link on POUT. It retails for $23.70.
What are dupes for Rare Beauty Toffee 2?
POUT uses CIEDE2000 color science to find the closest matches. Check the "Similar Shades" section above for the top 5 closest matches to Toffee 2.
Is Rare Beauty Toffee 2 matte or glossy?
Rare Beauty Toffee 2 has a satin finish.